| 1 | Northern Blend | I Want You, I Need You, I Love You | Lover Come Back to Me |
| 2 | A Cappella Showcase | Love Me Tender | When the Red Red Robin Comes Bob Bob Bobin Along |
| 3 | Niagara Frontier Chord Authority | Who Can I Turn To? | The Party's Over |
| 4 | Crystal Chords | Once Upon a Time | I'm Beginning to Like It |
| 5 | Rochester Rhapsody | I'm Nobody's Baby | You Belong to Me |
| 6 | Toronto Accolades | My Foolish Heart | Don't Break the Heart that Loves You |
| 7 | Sing Niagara | It's Only a Paper Moon | For All We Know |
| 8 | Liberty Belles Chorus | Oh Susanna, Dust Off that Old Pianna | When There's Love at Home |
| 9 | Harmony Falls | When You Wish Upon a Star | Razzle Dazzle |
