For 2009 Providence, RI - International Quartet Finals
| Order | Contestant | Song 1 title | Song 2 title |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Showcase | Cry Me a River | If I Had My Way |
| 2 | Ringtones! | They Say It's Wonderful | Yes Sir, That's My Baby |
| 3 | FUSION | Stop Callin' Me Baby | All Dressed Up with a Broken Heart |
| 4 | Foreign Exchange | Drivin' Me Crazy | For Sale, One Broken Heart |
| 5 | The Twilights | My Buddy | That's My Weakness Now / That Certain Party |
| 6 | Stardust | Cuddle Up a Little Closer, Lovey Mine | Lover Come Back to Me |
| 7 | Four Eyes | Swingin' On a Star (Parody) | Side By Side (Parody) |
| 8 | Cloud 9 | Over the Rainbow | Birth of the Blues |
| 9 | UniQue | Ballin' the Jack | If I Love Again |
| 10 | The Karamels | Secrets | When the Red Robin Comes Bobbin' Along |
